06.08.2026
Seller Wants $1M, Buyer Says $200K: Where the $800,000 Valuation Gap Comes From
Short answer: a seller prices a business on what it earned with him in charge; a buyer prices it on what it will earn after he leaves. In a typical small service company, the distance between those two numbers is the gap between a 10x and a 2x multiple — on $100,000–150,000 of annual profit, roughly $800,000.
Key points
- A buyer pays for the cash flow that survives the owner’s exit, not for the company’s history.
- The owner’s pay, owner-held assets and below-market rent all have to be restated at today’s market price.
- A multiple is a bet on how many years the current profit is secure. Two clients with 80% of revenue, or a lease about to reset, cut it sharply.
- Preparing for a sale should start a year ahead at the latest — ideally from the day the business becomes profitable.
The situation
An ordinary service business. The owner says: the company has cleared $120,000–150,000 a year for seven years, it is stable, and he has heard at business forums that ten times profit is normal — so, a million dollars. The buyer runs his own numbers and comes back with $200,000. Both are looking at the same company.
1. What the business earns without the owner
The first and simplest test: how much will the company make once the founder walks out — together with the quiet optimizations he has built up over ten or fifteen years? Often the sales run through him personally. Some employees stay out of loyalty to him and may leave with him. Part of the team may not have had a raise in a decade, which will not survive a change of owner.
So every cost has to be repriced at today’s market. Start with the owner’s own pay. He may draw $40,000 in salary and show $100,000 of profit — $150,000 in total. If a hired director for a business like this costs $150,000 a year, the profit a buyer actually acquires is close to zero.
2. What leaves with the owner
- Vehicles and equipment carried in the accounts but titled to the owner personally. He takes them with him.
- Premises rented from a relative, a partner or a friend on friendly terms. When the lease is signed again with a new owner, the rent moves to market — sometimes several times higher.
- The condition of the equipment. Machinery may be running on its last reserves or already obsolete and due for replacement. That cost belongs to the buyer.
3. Where the 10x multiple comes from — and why it is usually wrong
Ten times profit is a number sellers pick up from venture conversations and business seminars. For a small private company it rarely holds. A multiple is, in essence, the number of years a buyer can count on today’s profit. Can the seller show that it will hold for ten years? For five? For two?
Two things cut it fast. If two clients bring 80% of revenue, the multiple is only as long as their contracts: a five-year project gives five years, a year-to-year agreement gives one. And if the lease ends soon and the rent has not moved in ten years while the market has, the profit can disappear the day a new lease is signed.
What a seller should do
Start preparing at least a year before a sale — better, from the moment the business reaches steady profit. Keep proper records and accounts. Once a quarter, look at the company the way a buyer would: what would they check, what would they question? Decide what happens to relatives on the payroll; in a sale they usually count against the price. Replace worn equipment, clear out dead stock, fix the numbers that can be fixed.
The seller always wants more and the buyer always wants less. The real question is whose arguments hold up. In this example, that question is worth $800,000.
Frequently asked questions
What multiple is realistic for a small service business?
It depends on how long today’s profit is secure. With a spread of clients, long contracts and a market-rate lease it can be meaningfully higher. With concentrated clients or a lease about to reset, it can fall to two times profit.
Why restate the owner’s salary?
Because the buyer will have to pay someone to run the company. If the owner under-pays himself, reported profit is overstated by exactly that difference.
When should I start preparing a business for sale?
No later than a year before. Ideally, from the day the company becomes profitable.
Selling or buying a privately held company? See how I work with business owners, or fill in the questionnaire — I reply personally within two business days.